Converged.AI × BrandInsightAI
BrandInsightAI Insights
Automotive · refreshed weekly

How AI wants used cars

Used Cars is decided on attraction: Auto Trader indexes 138 there against Auto Village at 72, a 66-point spread. Auto Trader holds the strongest overall profile at 133 — complete desire. Across these 25 brands, attraction tracks being named most closely (rank correlation 0.55).

25 brands · 60 AI answers · 385 dimension scores · measured, never estimated

Attraction Standing out in the answer: named first, described as superior, magnetic and influential.
Affinity Belonging in the answer: tied to identity, values and legitimacy, not just specifications.
Attachment Staying in the answer: recommended again, dependable, easy, part of the routine.
AttractionAffinityAttachment Each whorl lights one ring per index threshold cleared (90 / 96 / 102 / 108 / 115)
Automotive

Used Cars

#Brand AttractionAffinityAttachment Desire shapeNamed in
1 Auto Trader: Attraction 138, Affinity 133, Attachment 129Auto Trader 138 133 129 Complete desire 8%
2 Carwow: Attraction 126, Affinity 111, Attachment 110Carwow 126 111 110 Complete desire 3%
3 CarGurus: Attraction 115, Affinity 111, Attachment 117CarGurus 115 111 117 Complete desire 0%
4 Cazoo: Attraction 126, Affinity 111, Attachment 108Cazoo 126 111 108 Complete desire 2%
5 Arnold Clark: Attraction 112, Affinity 121, Attachment 110Arnold Clark 112 121 110 Complete desire 0%
6 Cinch: Attraction 117, Affinity 104, Attachment 108Cinch 117 104 108 Complete desire 0%
7 Parkers: Attraction 109, Affinity 116, Attachment 108Parkers 109 116 108 Complete desire 0%
8 PistonHeads: Attraction 117, Affinity 113, Attachment 102PistonHeads 117 113 102 Magnetic but unbought 0%
9 HeyCar: Attraction 109, Affinity 104, Attachment 110HeyCar 109 104 110 Complete desire 0%
10 eBay Motors: Attraction 107, Affinity 108, Attachment 101eBay Motors 107 108 101 Quietly trusted 2%
11 JCT600: Attraction 98, Affinity 108, Attachment 98JCT600 98 108 98 Quietly trusted 0%
12 Motors: Attraction 98, Affinity 96, Attachment 105Motors 98 96 105 Habit, not love 2%
13 Car Delivery: Attraction 95, Affinity 88, Attachment 101Car Delivery 95 88 101 Habit, not love 0%
14 Big Motoring World: Attraction 90, Affinity 91, Attachment 98Big Motoring World 90 91 98 Habit, not love 0%
15 Car Shop: Attraction 90, Affinity 91, Attachment 101Car Shop 90 91 101 Habit, not love 0%
16 Bristol Street Motors: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Bristol Street Motors 90 96 93 Fading 0%
17 Evans Halshaw: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Evans Halshaw 90 96 93 Fading 0%
18 Lookers: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Lookers 90 96 93 Fading 0%
19 Pendragon: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Pendragon 90 96 93 Fading 0%
20 Perrys: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Perrys 90 96 93 Fading 0%
21 Vertu Motors: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93Vertu Motors 90 96 93 Fading 0%
22 Imperial Cars: Attraction 90, Affinity 88, Attachment 93Imperial Cars 90 88 93 Fading 0%
23 Exchange Mart: Attraction 74, Affinity 88, Attachment 87Exchange & Mart 74 88 87 Fading 0%
24 Carzam: Attraction 81, Affinity 71, Attachment 80Carzam 81 71 80 Fading 0%
25 Auto Village: Attraction 72, Affinity 71, Attachment 75Auto Village 72 71 75 Fading 0%

Indexed against the used cars average of 25 brands (100 = the category), measured across 60 AI answers in the latest weekly run.

Driver by driver

Where the category actually separates. A wide spread means assistants describe these brands very differently on that driver; a narrow one means it is table stakes.

Attraction

66-point spread · tracks being named 0.55
Auto Trader138
Auto Village72

The widest field of the three: this is where the category separates.

Affinity

62-point spread · tracks being named 0.42
Auto Trader133
Auto Village71

Real separation, but not the category’s defining contest.

Attachment

54-point spread · tracks being named 0.47
Auto Trader129
Auto Village75

The tightest of the three: most brands land close together here.

The shapes AI leaves these brands in

Three indices make a profile, and profiles fall into recognisable shapes. A brand that is magnetic but unbought has a different problem from a habit nobody loves — and a different thing to build next.

Auto Trader: Attraction 138, Affinity 133, Attachment 129
Complete desire
Wanted, belonged-to and repurchased — the rare full spiral.
Auto Trader · Carwow · CarGurus · Cazoo · Arnold Clark · Cinch · Parkers · HeyCar
Nothing obviously missing.
PistonHeads: Attraction 117, Affinity 113, Attachment 102
Magnetic but unbought
AI admires it and forgets to recommend buying it again.
PistonHeads
Build next: attachment
Motors: Attraction 98, Affinity 96, Attachment 105
Habit, not love
Recommended for reliability and ease; nobody calls it exciting.
Motors · Car Delivery · Big Motoring World · Car Shop
Build next: attraction
eBay Motors: Attraction 107, Affinity 108, Attachment 101
Quietly trusted
Legitimacy carries it; it is rarely named first.
eBay Motors · JCT600
Build next: attraction
Bristol Street Motors: Attraction 90, Affinity 96, Attachment 93
Fading
Below the benchmark everywhere; the answer has moved on.
Bristol Street Motors · Evans Halshaw · Lookers · Pendragon · Perrys · Vertu Motors · Imperial Cars · Exchange & Mart · Carzam · Auto Village
Build next: attraction

What assistants actually talk about

The sixteen dimensions underneath the drivers, scored 0–10 on how the answers describe each brand. Spread is the distance between the strongest and weakest brand: the widest are where a brand can still separate itself, the narrowest are the price of entry.

Where brands separate

DimensionDriverCategory avgStrongestSpread
Differentiation vs Sameness Attraction 6.0 Auto Trader 9.0 5.0
Leadership & Momentum Attraction 5.8 Auto Trader 9.0 5.0
Range & Availability Attachment 7.4 Auto Trader 10.0 5.0
Boldness & Creativity Attraction 5.5 Cazoo 8.0 4.0
Delivery & Fulfilment Attachment 6.4 Car Delivery 9.0 4.0

Where everyone reads alike

DimensionDriverCategory avgStrongestSpread
Value & Pricing Attachment 6.5 Auto Trader 8.0 3.0
Sustainability & Ethics Affinity 5.2 Auto Trader 7.0 3.0
Style & Aesthetic Attraction 5.4 Auto Trader 7.0 3.0
Customer Service & Support Attachment 6.3 Auto Trader 8.0 3.0
Reliability & Consistency Attachment 6.2 Auto Trader 8.0 3.0

Does desire track being recommended?

Rank correlation between a brand's driver index and the share of answers naming it, across the 25 indexed brands in this category. A relationship inside one run's answers — descriptive, never causal, and easily moved by a single brand at this sample size.

Attraction0.55
Affinity0.42
Attachment0.47

Method & limitations

Every week, each category runs a fixed set of unbranded consumer prompts against ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. A separate model reads the answers and scores every brand named in them across 16 perception dimensions, 0–10. Those dimensions are grouped into the three Drivers of Desire from the Havas Science of Desire framework, and each brand's driver score is indexed against the average of every scored brand in its category — 100 is the category, 115 is fifteen per cent above it.

This measures how AI assistants describe brands in their answers. It is not a survey of people, and it is not an endorsement: the scores are a reading of machine-generated text at the time of the run, and relationships between drivers and how often a brand is named are correlational. A brand needs at least six scored dimensions in a run to be indexed, and a category needs at least four such brands to get a board. See the full methodology.